A precedent-setting use of the OPPCBA before the OLRB to challenge longstanding bargaining unit exclusions.
Employers and unions have long assumed that employees with titles such as Supervisor, Manager, or Human Resources belong outside the bargaining unit because of their perceived connection to management or access to confidential information.
A recent precedent-setting decision from the Ontario Labour Relations Board (“OLRB”) demonstrates that those assumptions may not always hold true.
On October 30, 2026, the OLRB released its decision in Ontario Provincial Police Association v. Ontario Provincial Police, OLRB Case No. 2677-23-M, finding that the Talent Services Analyst position, a human resources role within the OPP, was not excluded from the Ontario Provincial Police Association’s (“OPPA”) civilian bargaining unit under the Ontario Provincial Police Collective Bargaining Act, 2006.
The case, argued by Riley Palmer, Partner at Watson Palmer Labour Lawyers, is the conclusion of a long fight. The precedential value cannot be understated, as it marks the first time the parties have utilized the Ontario Provincial Police Collective Bargaining Act, 2006 to challenge an employer’s exclusion of employees from the bargaining unit at the Ontario Labour Relations Board.
This matter was not determined at a single appearance. The application was initially processed before Lindsay Lawrence, then serving as Alternate Chair of the Ontario Labour Relations Board. In her February 21, 2024 decision, she recognized the significance of the dispute and noted that it appeared to be the first application brought under section 2(4) of the Ontario Provincial Police Collective Bargaining Act, 2006.
Following those preliminary proceedings, the matter proceeded before Derek L. Rogers, Vice-Chair of the Ontario Labour Relations Board, who conducted the hearing and ultimately issued a comprehensive 44-page merits decision on October 30, 2026.
In that decision, Vice-Chair Rogers declared that the HR Talent Services Analyst position was not excluded from the civilian employees’ bargaining unit and may therefore be included in the bargaining unit represented by the OPPA.
More broadly, the ruling reinforces a fundamental principle of labour law: bargaining unit status depends on what employees actually do, not what their job title suggests.
Looking Beyond the Job Title
Under Ontario labour legislation, employees who exercise managerial functions or work in a confidential labour relations capacity may be excluded from a bargaining unit. However, those exclusions are interpreted narrowly.
The OLRB focuses on evidence of an employee’s actual responsibilities, not their title, department, or historical classification. Supervising staff, assigning work, maintaining personnel records, or handling sensitive information will not automatically justify an exclusion. The key question is whether the employee genuinely exercises managerial authority or performs confidential labour relations functions. The evidentiary onus, in these cases, rests with the party seeking to exclusion exemption.
Why This Decision Matters
The OPPA challenged the longstanding exclusion of HR Talent Services Analysts, arguing that their day-to-day responsibilities did not satisfy the statutory requirements for exclusion.
The OLRB agreed. Despite handling sensitive employee information and participating in human resources processes, the evidence did not establish that the Analysts exercised managerial authority or performed confidential labour relations work sufficient to remove them from the bargaining unit.
Perhaps most importantly, the Board rejected the notion that a position remains excluded simply because it has always been treated that way. Historical practice, on its own, cannot replace evidence.
For unions and employers alike, the decision is a reminder that bargaining unit classifications should be regularly examined to ensure they remain legally justified. As workplaces evolve and roles change, longstanding assumptions may no longer reflect the reality of the work being performed.
Takeaway
The OPPA decision sends a clear message: exclusions are determined by substance, not labels.
Whether a position is called Supervisor, Manager, HR Analyst, or something else entirely, the question remains the same: do the employee’s actual duties justify exclusion under the legislation?
According to the OLRB, that answer cannot be based on title, tradition, or assumption alone. It must be based on actual evidence.
DISCLAIMER
The content within this blog is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other professional advice or an opinion of any kind. Watson Palmer Labour Lawyers does not warrant or guarantee the quality, accuracy or completeness of any information contained in this blog.
If you would like more information or have a specific question you would like to discuss with our Firm, please contact us by email at jfalcioni@watsonpalmerlaw.com
About the Author
Meghan is a Student-At-Law at Watson Palmer Labour Lawyers and will be joining the firm as an Associate later this year. Meghan obtained her law degree from the Hillary Rodham Clinton School of Law at Swansea University in the United Kingdom and has completed her Honours Bachelor of Arts in Gender and Social Justice studies from Trent University.
Meghan has a strong interest in union-side labour and employment law, with a particular focus on human rights and workplace protections. She has been exposed to a wide range of labour relations issues and is committed to supporting unions in protecting and advancing the rights of their members.
*Reviewed by a Partner