A Strike by Any Other Name…

On January 11th, the Ontario Labour
Relations Board (OLRB) issued a decision on the teachers’ unions’ planned
one-day protest of the collective agreements that were imposed on them under
the Putting Students First Act (PSFA).  The decision found that the planned
protests, in substance, were strikes and were therefore illegal.

On January 9th, the Elementary Teachers’
Federation of Ontario (ETFO) announced that it planned to have its members
participate in a “day of protest” or “political protest” over the imposed
collective agreements. The protest was to occur on Friday, January 11th.
The protest was to include a full-day withdrawal of services by ETFO members.

The question for the OLRB was whether the planned
political protest would constitute an illegal strike. The Collective Agreements
were imposed by order of the Lieutenant Governor in Council under authority of
section 9(2) of the PSFA. Under both section
9(4) of the Act and various sections of the Ontario Labour Relations Act (LRA) a strike or lockout in defiance of such
an order is illegal.

“Strike” is defined in section 1 of the LRA in the following way:

“strike” includes a
cessation of work, a refusal to work or to continue to work by employees in
combination or in concert or in accordance with a common understanding, or a
slow-down or other concerted activity on the part of employees designed to
restrict or limit output.

One of the problems faced by the ETFO was that the
planned protest included a cessation of work via the withdrawal of services.
Further, there is a fairly large line of Board decisions which find “political
strikes” to nevertheless be strikes and consequently illegal during a
collective agreement. The ETFO argued that the precedents did not apply in this
situation because the situation of the ETFO was different from those past
decisions in that the current situation of the ETFO involved the protest of
collective agreements that had been imposed on them. The other decisions
concerned the protest of freely negotiated collective agreements. The Board was
not swayed by this argument, finding that if ETFO’s position were to succeed it
would undermine the purposes of the PSFA.
Further, any Charter argument in support of the planned protest was rejected,
with the Board stating:

am I persuaded that the Charter protection afforded to speech (whether “labour
speech” or speech generally) outweighs the disruption that will be wrought on
the statutory labour relations scheme by ETFO’s position…

Having made these determinations, the Board decided
that the proposed planned day of protest would constitute an illegal strike. Though disagreeing with the decision
the union leadership asserted their respect for the decision-making authority
of the OLRB.

While this was a sound judgment based on the current
laws, the decision only further highlights how onerous the PSFA is. In imposing collective agreements, the Act has not only
stripped the teachers of their right to strike, it has severely stifled the
ability of teachers to voice dissent in any effective way. The precedent this
sets is worrisome. Dissent is a bedrock principle to the health of our
democracy. Every healthy and robust democracy allows for dissent. The ability
to dissent, in other words, is the canary in the coal mine when it comes to measuring
the health of a democracy. While it’s true that this is arguably only one
indication of a democracy’s health, it is a nevertheless a vital indicator.

The ETFO is litigating the constitutionality of Bill
115 (and the PSFA) in court. We hope
the court will take measures to correct the grievous violations of
Charter-protected rights wrought by Bill 115 and restore some semblance of
democratic order to Ontario.


You may also like

Lufthansa Flights Canceled Due to Strike

Lufthansa Flights Canceled Due to Strike

We Have a lot to Thank Unions For

We Have a lot to Thank Unions For

This Week in the History of the International Labour Movement Wagner Act

This Week in the History of the International Labour Movement Wagner Act
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Subscribe to our Bulletin now!